as Lucy Burrows
as Stoneman's Daughter Elsie
as The Woman Who Rocks the Cradle
as Rachel Cooper
as Letty
as Mattilda Zachary
as Anna Moore
as Herself, Archive footage
as Laura Belle McCanles
as Mother Mary of Mercy
as Mrs. Summers
as Self
as Hetty Seibert
as Elsie (archive footage) (uncredited)
as Susie May Trueheart
